Services  |  Data Integration  |  Analytics  |  Marketing Support  |  Account Management  |  Mobile Gives
eNewsletters

M3 Mobile Marketing e-Newsletter (December 2009)

 

Santa takes on texting at Burnsville Center

By Scott Carlson

Santa Claus may be still receiving bags full of letters at the North Pole. But these days, Jolly Old St. Nick is also embracing a new form of communication: cell phone texting.

In what is a first for a Twin Cities shopping center, Burnsville Center officials announced that children, in addition to visiting Santa Claus at their mall, can also, for a nominal fee, receive text messages from him.

“Santa can now send children mobile phone text messages that he ‘cant w8 2 visit them xmas eve’ and tell them about his preparations for the big night via Web videos,” said Burnsville Center officials in a press release, referring to Santa texting that debuted last week.

Santa texting is part of a bigger online marketing push at Burnsville Center to drive shopper traffic and sales to the mall during the holiday season, said an executive at Burnsville Center’s corporate parent, Chattanooga, Tenn.-based CBL & Associates Properties Inc.

“We are working to implement this program at 86 CBL shopping centers across the country,” said Barb Faucette, CBL vice president of corporate mall marketing. “This company did test the program in a few areas last year, but we are the first shopping center developer to launch the program nationwide.”

In giving Santa’s In giving Santa’s communications a high-tech update, Faucette said, “We thought [Santa texting] was clever, something fun, trendy and different that would appeal to children. We think it adds to the whole holiday experience for the kids.”

 

Competition is Great:  A Comparative Look at iPhone, Blackberry, and Droid

By Eric Ruttenbur

As winter draws near, the mobile handset space is heating up.  Just in time for the holidays, Verizon Wireless released a new smartphone called the “Droid.”  The Verizon Wireless hype machine is in full effect via a barrage of ads touting “Droid does.”  But does it live up to the hype?  How does it compare with the existing titans, iPhone and Blackberry?  Read on to find out more.


BlackBerry

BlackBerry is the old dog on the block.   The BlackBerry is a smartphone coming from business roots and it still excels at business functions such as e-mail capabilities and security.  For example, using the BlackBerry Enterprise Server (BES), you can remotely wipe a device should it get stolen or lost.  However, it runs on a proprietary platform that leaves a lot to be desired in terms of usability, performance, and open development.  Also, the learning curve on the BlackBerry is quite high for a first-time user.  Options on slightly older models such as the Curve, 8830 World Edition, Bold, etc. can be somewhat difficult to find.  Menus can get cluttered very fast.  Setting up accounts and getting the smartphone up and running can require a tech geek’s assistance for some.  Furthermore, BlackBerrys are slow.  Startup times, web browsing, and even navigating applications lag behind the competition.  You can get some quality time snoozing-in while waiting for a web page to load on a BlackBerry.  Lastly, the BlackBerry App World has apps, but most are not “polished” like their Android or iPhone equivalents. This can be very frustrating for a user that paid good money for a smartphone looking for great apps to accompany it.

iPhone

The iPhone originally came out Summer 2007 and is only available on AT&T.  It is still king in terms of usability and sleekness.  What can I say, it’s Apple!  They have consistently created intuitive interfaces in all of their devices from the iPod to the iPhone.  Most customers seem to find the iPhone easy to use even though it does not have a physical keyboard.  And although it does not have a removable battery, there are multiple charging options available including car chargers, USB to your PC, etc.  In addition, it is very thin and light compared to the Droid and BlackBerry.

It uses a proprietary platform called iPhone OS, but allows developers to create applications for it which can be sold on the App Store (if approved by Apple).  There have been numerous complaints about Apple’s approval process.  That said, there are still over 100,000 apps in the App Store, so if you’re looking for quantity, the iPhone has it!  Apps range from the just plain silly (iSteam – simulates a steamed up screen) to very useful (iSplit – helps figure out how to split up a restaurant bill w/ tip and tax).

Droid

The Droid is the new kid on the block.  It was released November 6, 2009 and it is only available on Verizon Wireless.  The Droid was developed via collaboration between Verizon Wireless, Motorola, and Google.  It is slightly thicker and heavier than the iPhone, but feels very durable.  The droid features a 5 megapixel camera with Flash.  The Droid also features a physical keyboard, but it can take some getting used to as the keys are very tight and almost flat.  I am not sure it was worth adding the weight and size for the keyboard in this case.  It features an interchangeable battery so if your battery is running low, you could put another one in.  It also supports Wi-Fi and has a GPS chip.

The Droid runs an open-source platform called Android 2.0.  Open-source means that anyone can take a look at the building blocks and customize it to their needs.  Android-powered devices feature access to the Android Market which currently has almost 20,000 apps.  In my experience with the Droid, I have found it to be intuitive and very responsive.  If you already use Google services, transitioning to the Droid will be very easy.  In fact, if you store your contacts in Gmail, Outlook, or Facebook, you will not even need to pay to have your contacts transferred over from your old phone to your new smartphone.  The Droid will automatically sync this information for you. Also, one of the first things I noticed after setting up my e-mail account is that the default new mail tone is a rather loud, robotic voice saying, “Droooiiiiiddd.”  It was a bit much!  Of course, this can be easily changed to be a different tone or silent.   Another nice perk is pre-installed Google Maps with turn-by-turn navigation.  For VZW subscribers, this means the $10/month for VZ Navigator is no longer necessary!  The Droid also features native one-touch, voice-activated Google search right on the home screen.  It is very convenient to have Google available wherever you go.

Conclusion

I wouldn’t say the Droid is an “iPhone killer,” in the sense that a happy AT&T iPhone user should switch to Verizon Wireless for the Droid. However, I will say that the debut Droid is a comparable and capable device.  By capable, I mean that it is many devices in one.  It can replace your existing alarm clock (with the optional multimedia dock), Tom-Tom (with the optional car mount), iPod, or even your computer in most cases.  Give the Droid another year or two and I believe it will compare to the iPhone in all aspects including size/weight, apps, and ease of use.

I feel that all three devices are great in their own respects.  If you’re a business user concerned with security, I would recommend a BlackBerry coupled with the BlackBerry Enterprise Server at your workplace.  Otherwise, if you are happy with your carrier, then stick with the device your carrier supports:  iPhone for AT&T subscribers and Droid for Verizon Wireless subscribers.

Here’s a chart pitting the three devices against each other across various capabilities.

 Feature

Winner

Why

Display

Droid

Higher more vibrant resolution

Ease of use

iPhone

It’s Apple; pioneers in usability innovation.

Security

BlackBerry

Obama uses a BlackBerry, ‘nuff said.

Speed

Droid

Better hardware specs; platform handles simultaneously running apps

Camera

Tie

No clear winner, all have good specs but all are lackluster cameras overall (after all, it’s still a cell phone camera)

Apps

iPhone

iPhone has the most apps, currently at over 100,000.

 

Isn’t competition a great thing?  We can just sit back and watch the innovation develop!

 

Shoppers Hunt for Online Deals

By Monica Alleven

Expectations were high for Cyber Monday, but the big questions are how much of that cyber shopping was done either with mobile phones or for mobile phones?

The National Retail Federation (NRF) says more Americans planned to shop online on Cyber Monday than last year. Citing a survey conducted for Shop.org by BIGresearch, the NRF says 96.5 million Americans planned to shop on Cyber Monday this year, up from 85 million in 2008.

An estimated 3.8 percent of Cyber Monday shoppers shopped from a mobile device like an iPhone or BlackBerry.

The Wall Street Journal also reports that Black Friday saw greater use of mobile phones to make purchases. Mobile online payments through PayPal surged nearly 650 percent, according to the report. TheFind.com reported searches from mobile devices this year were up to about 200,000 from 5,000 on Black Friday in 2008, the report said.

Meanwhile, carriers hoped to cash in on some of the Cyber Monday craze with Web-only deals. For a limited time via its site, Sprint is offering five devices for free with a new two-year service agreement.

Among the featured devices: the Samsung Reclaim, LG Rumor2, SCP-2700 by Sanyo, Motorola i776w and Sierra U598. The Samsung Exclaim is going for $49.99 after rebate and with a new two-year contract. The Consumer Electronics Association (CEA) says strong November sales continued into Black Friday weekend. CEA predicts volume growth of 6 percent this holiday compared with a significant decline last year. CEA's 16th annual holiday purchase patterns study also shows 80 percent of adults intend to buy technology as a gift this holiday, the highest figure in the history of the study.

 

Four Ways to Simplify a Mobile Marketing Campaign

By Sean Carton

If you're going to develop mobile marketing that works, you have to pay attention to four simple things:

Where is the person you're trying to reach? Location-based technologies (such as those found in the iPhone and in Android phones with Google's new location-finding technology) mean that you can take advantage of someone's physical location when targeting your messages.

What are they doing? A businessperson trying to figure out where to get a cab, take a client to dinner, or find their way to their hotel in a strange city is a much different target than some 20-something out for a night on the town. Targeting messages based on the context of the consumer's situation makes your message much more effective.

Who is the person encountering your mobile marketing? While figuring this out isn't all that different from what we normally do when developing ads in any medium, understanding who you're trying to reach in the context of where they are and what they're trying to do is vital for reaching consumers.

Why are they using their device? Are they trying to communicate with their friends? Are they trying to find something? Are they trying to entertain themselves while sitting on the subway?

Make no mistake about it: mobile marketing is different than any other form of marketing because it's the context that matters as much as the content. As we move forward in our efforts to reach consumers with mobile marketing, developing campaigns that address these four simple questions will help you develop mobile marketing strategies that work.

 

Survey: Future Spend For Mobile Marketing

By Mobile Marketing Watch

We hear a lot from so-called “industry experts” or analysts who make huge claims as to how mobile marketing is going to “take off” this year, or that this year “isn’t quite the year for mobile marketing” and so on.  Most of the time these claims are based purely on opinion and lack any real substance.

A new survey decided to go directly to the source — meaning major brands and advertisers themselves– to see just how mobile marketing is working out for them, and to get an understanding as to how they plan on spending their marketing dollars using the mobile channel in the future.

100 leading agencies were surveyed to compile an in-depth analysis of mobile advertising performance and forecasts of future spending.  Dubbed “The State of the Industry,” the survey compiled data to provide a critical view on where the industry stands today, where the industry is and is not, and why agencies and publishers are planning to buy mobile in the future.

The survey indicated that 60 percent of non-mobile marketers are planning to employ some form of mobile advertising in 2010.  Subsequently, the increase in mobile spend was one of the more surprising aspects of the survey’s results.  Out of those surveyed; 31 percent of agency respondents stated they will invest between $100K and $249K next year, while more than 15 percent stated they plan on investing over $1 million.

More than half of Q4 mobile campaigns will represent between 1 percent and 10 percent of their client’s total spending, but for a few, the number could be an impressive 40-50 percent.  Overall though, nearly three quarters of the respondents stated that they had developed mobile campaigns for themselves or their clients, while around 28 percent hadn’t utilized mobile at all.  To me, a leading agency that doesn’t utilize the mobile channel for their clients shouldn’t be a leading agency at all.

When it comes to how mobile marketing is performing overall, 78 percent of respondents said the medium met their campaign goals, while an additional 9 percent said mobile performed “beyond our wildest expectations.”  Nearly one third of respondents stated that mobile has become an “indispensable” part of their media mix, while another 67 percent ranked mobile as “somewhat valuable” and only 2 percent said it wasn’t valuable at all.

It’s interesting to note that nearly 89 percent of respondents indicated that mobile was only a small part of a much larger multi-platform buy, and that internal resources remain the number one barrier to entry into the mobile channel.  More than 80 percent of agencies surveyed, who have participated in mobile campaigns, have hired or developed internal resources to support them.  Agencies expressed concern over the fact that it still involves multiple partners to “expertly execute on the promise of mobile media,” meaning things like technology partners, metrics, buying networks and app developer resources, among others.

Still, it’s always interesting to get a better understanding of how mobile is being used and what the future plans are for those who are actually involved in the practice of mobile marketing.